User talk:Jplu: Difference between revisions
GerardKuys (talk | contribs) (Asked not to add subclasses to the DBpedia ontology for each geographical region) |
GerardKuys (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| (5 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Hi Julien, | |||
O, I see. Apologies for my misunderstanding! | |||
Regards, | |||
Gerard | |||
Hi Julien, | |||
Could you please explain what you had in mind when adding the properties 'shoeSize' and 'penisLength'? Do they serve a particular goal or were they just a (bad) joke? | |||
Regards, | |||
Gerard | |||
Hi Gerard, | |||
No it's not a (bad) joke, these properties are used in the French Wikipedia infoboxes, one for pornographic actors and the other for models. | |||
Regards, | |||
Julien. | |||
[[User:Jplu|Jplu]] 16:47, 17 Junuary 2014 (UTC) | |||
Hi Julien, | |||
I also deleted three classes you created (JapanPrefecture, FrenchIntercommunality & AmericanState) | |||
We *should* get the place from other prorties like "country" etc not the class itself | |||
Best, | |||
Dimitris | |||
[[User:Jimkont|Jimkont]] 14:47, 7 June 2013 (UTC) | |||
Hi Jplu, | Hi Jplu, | ||
| Line 10: | Line 46: | ||
[[User:GerardKuys|GerardKuys]] 07:56, 7 June 2013 (UTC) | [[User:GerardKuys|GerardKuys]] 07:56, 7 June 2013 (UTC) | ||
Hi, | |||
I removed all the class and replaced them by a constant like you said. | |||
Best. | |||
Latest revision as of 23:31, 17 January 2014
Hi Julien,
O, I see. Apologies for my misunderstanding!
Regards,
Gerard
Hi Julien,
Could you please explain what you had in mind when adding the properties 'shoeSize' and 'penisLength'? Do they serve a particular goal or were they just a (bad) joke?
Regards,
Gerard
Hi Gerard,
No it's not a (bad) joke, these properties are used in the French Wikipedia infoboxes, one for pornographic actors and the other for models.
Regards,
Julien. Jplu 16:47, 17 Junuary 2014 (UTC)
Hi Julien,
I also deleted three classes you created (JapanPrefecture, FrenchIntercommunality & AmericanState) We *should* get the place from other prorties like "country" etc not the class itself
Best, Dimitris Jimkont 14:47, 7 June 2013 (UTC)
Hi Jplu,
Recently, I noticed tht you have added to the DBpedia ontology a set of classes, a set of which each new class denotes nothing else than just a particular geographical region of the same type of class. I have in mind the subclasses you defined for superclasses Settlement and AdministrativeRegion, designating a Settlement in such and such country: AlgerianSettlement etc.
In my honest opinion, there really is no need to proliferate subclasses in this way. If you want to see individuals of the Settlement class for a particular country, there is the 'country' property you can use as a selection criteria. If it is because of any mapping you might want to make, you can add a constant mapping to your mapped template, saying that for this template the 'country' property should always point to Algeria, for instance.
If there would be a tendency for the DBpedia ontology to expand subclasses for any possible combination of criteria, I fear that to a great extent this would harm the usefulness of the ontology. If there is any particular kind of problem you might want to solve by adding subclasses in this way, I would be happy to think with you how this problem could be solved in another way.
With kind regards,
GerardKuys 07:56, 7 June 2013 (UTC)
Hi,
I removed all the class and replaced them by a constant like you said.
Best.
